Emerging market currencies have had a great start to the year. The slowdown in the world economy has forced the U.S. Federal Reserve to pause its interest rate hikesand the European Central Bank (ECB) to dial back plans for its first such move.
The relief in emerging markets has been evident: the dollar has given up 1.9% against the Mexican peso, 4.2% against the South African rand and a whopping 5.9% against the Russian ruble. But one of the big plays in EMFX has been left behind—and unjustly so, in the eyes of some.
The Turkish lira has only eked out a 0.3% gain against the dollar year-to-date, despite support from sky-high interest rates, a rapidly-improving balance of payments and encouraging—if still slow—signs of progress in tackling high corporate debt levels. Clearly, memories of last year’s rout, when the lira fell 45% in the six months to August after President Recep Tayyip Erdogan pressured the central bank not to raise interest rates, are still fresh and painful. Trust in a central bank and a currency takes only days to destroy, but months or even years to rebuild.
But last year’s collapse, while clearly induced by domestic policy, came against the background of rising dollar interest rates and expectations that the ECB, too, would move slowly towards raising its key rate. That outlook has now changed, and fears that big European banks such as Unicredit (MI:CRDI), ING (AS:INGA) and BBVA (MC:BBVA) would pull resources from their local subsidiaries and trigger a credit crunch have proved largely unfounded.
“Right now, we like the lira more than the ruble or the rand,” said Charles Robertson, head of research at emerging market specialist Renaissance Capital. He argued that the lack of a rebound from last year has left the lira 20% below its long-term average rate.
Additionally, Turkey’s official one-week repo rate—at 24% since September—means the lira offers huge positive carry relative to funding currencies like the dollar or euro, and a sizeable premium even to EM peers such to either South Africa (where official rates are at 6.75%) or Russia (7.75%). The country’s central bank, which is still rebuilding its credibility, promised after its last policy meeting it wouldn’t cut rates prematurely, despite lowering its forecasts for inflation this year and next. Inflation is still running at an annual rate of 20.35%.
ING economist Muhammet Mercan reckons the central bank won’t cut until June at the earliest, when basis effects will allow a “convincing” drop in the year-on-year inflation rate.
Clearly there are still risks ahead: The government’s announcement last week that it is looking at the possibility of nationalizing Isbank, the country’s largest listed bank, sends troubling signals; BBVA analysts highlight that the restructuring of corporate debt, after a decade-long binge on cheap dollars, needs to be speeded up. Geopolitically, the planned withdrawal of U.S. forces from northern Syria creates scope for various mishaps: not only is Erdogan vying for influence in the region with Iran, Saudi Arabia and Russia, but he risks a fresh spat with the U.S. over the Syrian Kurds, whom he suspects of aiding Kurdish rebels in Turkey.
The risk of political interference in economic policy also remains: Erdogan’s party faces mayoral and municipal elections across the country at the end of March. But for now the signs are that the government thinks it has more to lose than to gain from renewing its assault on the central bank.
For foreign investors at least, sentiment towards Turkey is improving. The Finance Ministry was able to sell bonds in both dollars and euros without problems in January. If the government can convince its own people, too, that it won’t repeat last year’s mistakes, the lira’s rebound should have further to go.
by Geoffrey Smith